National Gallery Australia: NGA x Replica furniture
As the problem with design theft in Australia escalates – it’s clearly apparent national gallery, museum and public institution decision makers simply don’t know what’s real and what’s fake. Either that, or they simply don’t care! Authenticity is core to a gallery collection – so why do purchasing decisions deviate to buy replicas of iconic furniture designs?
Surely everyone knows replica is fake?
In December 2016, during our first ADA Canberra event, concerned audience members were openly horrified about the (then) recent instalation of fake designer furniture in a public area of the National Gallery Australia (NGA).
A quick visit to NGA members lounge revealed a sea of counterfeit Fritz Hansen Swan chairs teamed with fake Florence Knoll sofas. The poorly constructed knock-off designs were clearly low grade copies that furnish a premium NGA supporter space.
Let’s forget for a moment that museums and galleries exist for the sole purpose of showcasing original works.
The NGA Members lounge features fake furniture sitting shoulder to shoulder with original armchairs by one of Australia’s most designers Grant Featherston. The armchair created in the 1960’s is possibly one of the most famous of all Australian furniture designs.
Fast forward to the current Federal Government inquiry into Institutional Spending that provoked Canberra Times (Fairfax) to question the NGA spend on ORIGINAL Featherston chairs in the face of recent budget cuts. Budget cuts that prompted slash and burn staff cuts.
Design in essence is careful consideration of every aspect of the product.
Who is it for? How will it be used? And importantly, how is it made?
GRANT FEATHERSTON, 1968
Is the real problem caused by diminishing Federal and State cultural funding?
‘NGA splashes on armchairs during budget cuts’ Canberra Times April 6, 2018
When the NGA were called out for furniture purchases in the upgraded members lounge – we had to point out that given ORIGINAL Featherston designs form part of the NGA permanent collection (our image below) it’s only appropriate that authentic chairs are procurred.
“Museums, galleries and national institutions are obligated to display original, authentic works. Authenticity is the sole reason they exist. “ ADA director Anne-Maree Sargeant explained to Fairfax media.
“Imagine if visitors to London’s V&A or MoMA New York have to sit on fake furniture in cafes, courtyards or other spaces? It simply wouldn’t happen! So why are Australian institutions forced to cut corners thanks to small-focus budget decisions by Federal Funding bodies?”
READ our full response in the Canberra Times follow up [April 12, 2018]
3 facts we presented //
1. NGA collection contains authentic Featherston furniture – and genuine chairs in the members lounge are the only appropriate option.
2. No museums or global galleries display counterfeits. Museums & Galleries exist to showcase original works. Replica is fake.
3. If you can’t afford original iconic designs – invest in Australian design. Locally designed products can be procurred for the same price as replicas.
What we learned //
Australian institutions must create internal purchasing mandates
- NO FAKE DESIGN or REPLICA products. Ever.
- INVEST IN AUSTRALIAN DESIGN if original icons are unaffordable
- Engage design professionals to consult on purchasing decisions outside staff expertise
That way everyone wins – right?